Total Pageviews

Thursday, 4 April 2013

Bedroom Tax - a legal view

Well so much has happened this week, it is hard to know where to start. 

I have spent a lot of time on the changes to personal injury claims. There are many other injustices on the horizon following 1st April – otherwise known as Black Monday.

One thing which does have huge legal implications is the Bedroom Tax. Supporters of the government deny that this in fact a ‘tax’ at all. It is in fact the reduction in Housing Benefit for poorer families who are deemed to have too many bedrooms. So if two children each have their own room – even if mixed sex in the case of under 10s – the tenant will be penalised. If a disabled adult needs their own room they will see a cut. If a couple have lived in a house for half their lives they will have money taken away if they have one or more unused bedrooms after the children fly the nest.

If it is money which is taken from tenants and benefits the treasury then is tax in my book! But this is not the place to discuss the pros and cons of the tax. What is clear is that there can and will be legal cases as a result. If a tenant’s rent is say £100 a week and they lose say £20 a week under the tax. The rent remains £100 regardless of whether the tenant can afford to pay. If the whole amount is not paid then arrears will accrue. If the arrears are not cleared the tenant faces eviction. Some have tried to argue that in fact nobody will lose their home as a result of the tax.

Social Landlords have said that they will have no choice but to evict tenants in arrears. They may do so with a heavy heart but cannot afford to do otherwise. One social landlord has gone as far as sending a form to tenants inviting them to sign to acknowledge their liability for the full rent in the case of any deduction.

The government say the aim is to encourage people to move of oversized accommodation. According to Conservative Party Chair Grant Schapps -

“It is wrong to leave people out in the cold with effectively no roof over their heads because the taxpayer is paying for rooms which aren’t in use. It’s just a common-sense reform, which in the end will help house more people.”

The problem is that almost all landlords say that there is no accommodation available for them to move to. It is a classic Catch 22.

To make matters worse Legal Aid has been drastically cut this week. As a result those tenants who most need legal help will not be able to get it.

I predict that we are going to see hundreds of cases arriving at the courts with unrepresented tenants. The judiciary has already complained that they will not be able to cope with the flood of similar cases.

Sadly it will probably take the first Bedroom Tax eviction to make the media take notice.


  1. Thank you for the informative post, Tax season can be very hectic and confusing for those that are not experienced in filing taxes. Luckily, there are plently of IRS tax help programs and websites.

  2. Like all these things if properly controlled and checks done these changes would be ok, so only those in a house definitely too big for them etc would be penalised and others who need the extra room would not be.

    Wrote about it here: People Urged to Defy Bedroom Tax

  3. But that doesn't answer the acknowledged lack of smaller accommodation in most areas..

  4. Hi there, nice post. This is an interesting and very informative topic. Thanks for sharing you thoughts on this issue. Keep it up, looking forward to read another one in the future. Cheers!

    boston lawyer

  5. What the heck is that bedroom tax. Government is really getting sicker. Can't believe what I am reading is actually true. Anyways, thank you for the article.

    Financial Claims Made Simple

  6. thanks for share..